How does the Bohr model of an atom differ from the modern theory?

Question

Adrian Ayala · Accepted Answer

Bohr thought that electrons orbited the nucleus in circular paths; whereas in the modern view atomic electron structure is more like 3D standing waves.

Bohr built upon Rutherford's model of the atom. In it most of the atom's mass is concentrated into the center (what we now call the nucleus ) and electrons surround the positive mass in something like a cloud. Bohr's most significant contribution was explaining the model using the quantification energy. He believed that electrons moved around the nucleus in circular orbits with quantised potential and kinetic energies.

In principle the quantification aspect of the model is still believed to be correct. The main problem lies in the idea of electrons in circular orbits. This does not satisfy the Heisenberg uncertainty principle, which is that it is not possible to know the position and momentum of a particle simultaneously. And also, it does not satisfy the fact that atoms have a 3D formation. If the orbitals are circular, the 3D structure of an atom is not probable.

An application of Schrödinger's equation to hydrogen's emission / absorption spectra it was shown that a standing wave energy level model corresponded to the emitted / absorbed photons. Scientists now use the idea of a probability cloud to describe electron distribution around the nucleus.

The probability clouds satisfy the Heisenberg uncertainty principle because the cloud only illustrate the probability of finding an electron in that space, not the certainty of finding it there. If you look carefully you can also observe the standing wave type formation of the clouds. Take a look at this image of hydrogen's probability clouds.

The Starck Effect and Zeeman Effect was not explainable because the concept of sub energy levels was not introduced.

(timeline of theories from 2500 yrs ago to modern theory. Bohr theory begins around 4 min mark)

Parker Abbott · Answer

undefined The Bohr model describes electrons in specific orbits, while the modern theory views electrons as existing within electron clouds or orbitals, where their exact locations are uncertain. Additionally, the modern model incorporates principles from quantum mechanics, providing a more detailed understanding of an atom's behavior.

Layla Ahmed · Answer

undefined The Bohr model of the atom suggests that electrons orbit the nucleus in fixed, circular orbits, much like planets orbiting the sun. However, according to modern quantum mechanics, electrons do not move in fixed orbits but rather exist in regions of probability called orbitals. These orbitals represent the likelihood of finding an electron in a particular region around the nucleus, rather than specific paths or trajectories. Additionally, the Bohr model fails to explain phenomena such as electron spin, electron-electron repulsion, and the behavior of atoms with more than one electron, which are addressed by modern quantum theory.